188 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757-1211, USA
(716) 753-2900


kelly shaw

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

We just recently dined there for my birthday and for the most part it was a great experience. The restaurant itself is very inviting and has a wonderful ambiance. The entrees we ordered were excellent but the calamari was chewy. For a more upscale restaurant we were looking forward to a more knowledgeable waitress especially with the price point. Our drinks weren’t filled and we weren’t checked on either by the waitress who wasn’t at all interactive at all with us. Last season we had a way better experience but we will definitely try it again this season. The tenderloin was amazing as well as the strip steak. The drinks were also fantastic!

Mike McLaughlin

Sunday, June 24, 2018

The Watermark saved our night last night. We attempted to go to an Italian restaurant down the road, and it was a complete disaster. We walked into the Watermark upset and frustrated, and left beyond satisfied. We had an excellent meal, excellent service and a great dinner. We will be back for sure. Thank you for saving our date night dinner before the Alison Krauss concert Watermark!!

Gregory Paris

Saturday, June 16, 2018

Nice lakeside restaurant with outdoor deck. Great for steaks and seafood. Solid wine and cocktails list.

Michelle Chiacchiari

Tuesday, July 10, 2018

Awesome atmosphere. Friendly staff. Tasty food.

Bill N

Friday, June 29, 2018

View of lake isn't that great. Building is dumpy looking on outside, inside isn't nothing to write home about. Food was mushy, pre made, and over priced.