The 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in New York!

Blessed with miles of coastline between Long Island and Manhattan, it’s no surprise that fishing—and, subsequently, seafood restaurants—are so popular. From casual waterfront fish-and-chips joints to an oyster bar on a sailboat docked in Tribeca, seafood lovers have a healthy variety of restaurants to choose from. Here are 10 of the best seafood restaurants in the Empire State. 

Gosman’s Dock Restaurant, Montauk, NY

Located on Montauk’s fishing docks, this family-owned restaurant is a local landmark. Try the lobster roll or the chowder, sit back, and watch the fishing boats come into the harbor with the day’s catch.

Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co., Brooklyn, NY

This clean, classy, New England-style fish market and restaurant draws in large crowds for its fish tacos and its popular oyster happy hour, among many other delicious reasons.

Grand Banks, New York, NY

Gorgeous and sophisticated, this New York City oyster bar is on the deck of a historic fishing boat on the Hudson in Tribeca, offering delicious seafood and incredible sunset views.

Oyster Bar, New York, NY

A dazzling cavernous space inside the also-dazzling-and-cavernous Grand Central Terminal, Oyster Bar has been hosting its delicious oyster happy hour and a diverse seafood menu for over a hundred years.

Luke’s Lobster, New York, NY

Business partners Luke Holden and Ben Conniff serve up fresh, meaty lobster-claw-and-knuckle rolls sourced directly from Luke’s father’s business, Portland Shellfish. The reasonably priced lobster roll restaurant has expanded to several other New York City neighborhoods.

Bostwick’s Chowder House, East Hampton, NY

This casual seafood spot has been a Hamptons hotspot for years. Expect an array of fresh-off-the-boat seafood like halibut, swordfish, and tuna, as well as comfort food classics like fried clams and lobster rolls. 

Harvest on Fort Pond, Montauk, NY

Harvest on Fort Pond is a beautiful restaurant in the heart of Montauk, serving up large, Zagat-rated, family-style dishes on its garden patio. Much of the menu is sourced from local fishing boats, New York farms, and its own garden.

Lunch Lobster Roll Restaurant, Amagansett, NY

With its red, white, and blue décor and iconic sign that reads “LUNCH,” this roadside seafood joint constantly has a line stretching out the door. Fans stop by for the lobster roll, fish and chips, and assortment of shellfish.

Anchor Down Bar and Grill, Merrick, NY

A Long Island favorite, this white linen-table clothed waterside establishment offers phenomenal seafood like Thai-seasoned mussels and lobster rolls to diners near Jones Beach.

Mermaid Oyster Bar, New York, NY

This is the place in New York City to find New-England-seafood-shack charm, an awesome oyster happy hour, and an educational oyster app called the “Oysterpedia.” It’s no wonder Mermaid has gained such a loyal fan base.

Share your favorites!
New York Search
Find Seafood Restaurants Near You
Select a New York town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Bronx County
New York County
Richmond County