10 Best Italian Restaurants in New York!

When it comes to Italian food, New York is the place to be. In the Empire State, you'll find all your favorite Italian dishes in eclectic restaurants, from high-end trattorias to family-run restaurants that have been around for generations. So if you're looking for the best of the best, look no further than this list of the 10 best Italian restaurants in New York.

Mario's, New Lebanon, NY

Mario's is everything that you want out of an Italian restaurant. This family-run eatery was opened in 1965 and serves upscale Italian fare in a cozy space with a fireplace. Guests say, "This place is truly a gem!"

Paolo Lombardi's Ristorante, Wynantskill, NY

Paolo Lombardi's Ristorante is a traditional date night restaurant in upstate New York. The intimate, elegant atmosphere is combined with traditional Italian cuisine, great wine, and the occasional candlelit kiss.

DiBella's Italian Market, Rochester, NY

When you think of the best Italian restaurants, you probably think of pasta. But at DiBella's Italian Market, you can get some of the best Italian sliced meats and subs in the state. "Fresh bread in multiple sizes so you had a sandwich for every appetite," raved one diner.

Mulberry Italian Ristorante, Buffalo, NY

Buffalo's top-rated Italian restaurant, Mulberry Italian Ristorante, is the place to go for a great meal. Locals recommend the meatball and sausage, but you can't go wrong choosing anything from the menu. One diner says, "I have never had such tasty Italian food anywhere else."

Antonio's Trattoria, Bronx, NY

Listed on Yelp's Favorite Places to Eat in 2022, Antonio's Trattoria serves up Italian comfort food like Nona used to make. Make a reservation; this popular Bronx establishment fills up quickly and is known for its delicious pasta dishes.

Lorenzo's Restaurant & Cabaret, Staten Island, NY

Lorenzo's Restaurant & Cabaret in Staten Island offers a show and great food. Join them for Sunday brunch, where you'll get an authentic Italian breakfast and a nice boozy beverage.

Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse, Utica, NY

Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse is a fabulous restaurant, no matter which location you visit. But the Utica location is especially beloved by patrons who love its classic Italian menu with nostalgic flavors.

La Cucina Di Mamma, Niagara Falls, NY

Diners who visit La Cucina Di Mamma say they enjoy a meal they won't soon forget. The Chicken Mama or Stuffed Peppers are two dishes that are sure to impress.

Osteria Danny, Saratoga Springs, NY

Osteria Danny in Saratoga Springs is a must-try. The restaurant has three menus that change with the seasons, chefs' moods, and the ingredients available, paired with incredible cocktails and wine.

Olio e PiĆ¹, New York City, NY

Out of the nearly 28,000 restaurants in New York City, Olio e Più ranks #3 for a good reason. This trattoria, which serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, specializes in classic Italian practices. The chef preps house-made pasta and pizza with a Neapolitan-style thin crust.

Share your favorites!
New York Search
Find Italian Restaurants Near You
Select a New York town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Bronx County
New York County
Richmond County