The 10 Best Hardware Stores in New York!

When you’re looking to start on a new home improvement project, the best place to get expert advice, all the supplies you’ll need, and a welcoming atmosphere, is a local hardware store. These stores are staples of the community. Thankfully for New Yorkers, the Empire State is home to plenty of these classic retailers. Here are the 10 best hardware stores in the state. 

1. Nuthouse Hardware, New York, NY

Open 24 hours a day, this four-story midtown hardware store is dedicated to customers. You can find nearly part you need—whether it’s hardware, tools, lumber, paint, etc.—and the knowledgeable staff will help you every step of the way.

2. Goldberg Hardware, Tarrytown, NY

If you're looking for an old-fashioned small-town hardware store that induces nostalgia, Goldberg Hardware in Tarrytown is just the place. The store’s shelves are stuffed with merchandise, and the helpful staff will help you locate anything you need.

3. Saifee Hardware & Garden, New York, NY

For more than 20 years, this East Village hardware store has been a destination for those looking to do a little home and garden work in the neighborhood. In addition to a large selection of tools and housewares, Saifee has a garden center with everything you need to make yours thrive.

4. Gersitz Hardware & Supply Co., Buffalo, NY

Since 1936, this locally owned shop has stocked everything from hardware to hot water heaters. With a slogan like “we have it if we can find it,” a hardware-shopping adventure is in store.

5. Garber Hardware, New York, NY

Since 1884, this West Village hardware store has been proudly owned and operated by the Garber family. Today, it’s still a reliable neighborhood source of all sorts of equipment, tools, paint, and supplies to aid in home improvement.

6. Old Forge Hardware, Old Forge, NY

Since 1900, Old Forge Hardware has been “the Adirondacks’ most general store,” offering everything from fishing and camping gear to gourmet food and, of course, a diverse selection of hardware, making it a local favorite.

7. E.R. Butler & Co. – NYC

This upscale New York City fixtures supplier is a destination for gorgeous custom hardware for the “doors, windows, and fine furniture” of the most exacting clients. The Prince Street showroom is open by appointment only.

8. Kings Park Hardware, Kings Park, NY

Opened in 2011 by the Tanzi family—longtime Kings Park residents who previously ran a lumberyard in the area—Kings Park Hardware offers a large inventory for Long Islanders who want to support local hardware stores.

9. Adirondack Hardware, Multiple locations

Small, local hardware store chain Adirondack Hardware sells a variety of tools, appliances, and equipment for homeowners, including furnaces, paint, car parts, and lawn and garden gear.

10. Mayer Paint & Hardware, Rochester, NY

With aisles packed with every imaginable part, free popcorn, Benjamin Moore paint, and an adorable Labrador retriever, it’s no wonder Mayer Paint & Hardware is such a beloved hardware store in Rochester.

Select a New York town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Find Hardware Stores Near You
Enter City / State or Zip code below
Select your town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you:

Albany County

Allegany County

Bronx County

Broome County

Cattaraugus County

Cayuga County

Chautauqua County

Chemung County

Chenango County

Clinton County

Columbia County

Cortland County

Delaware County

Dutchess County

Erie County

Essex County

Franklin County

Fulton County

Genesee County

Greene County

Hamilton County

Herkimer County

Jefferson County

Kings County

Lewis County

Livingston County

Madison County

Monroe County

Montgomery County

Nassau County

New York County

Niagara County

Oneida County

Onondaga County

Ontario County

Orange County

Orleans County

Oswego County

Otsego County

Putnam County

Queens County

Rensselaer County

Richmond County

Rockland County

Saint Lawrence County

Saratoga County

Schenectady County

Schoharie County

Schuyler County

Seneca County

Steuben County

Suffolk County

Sullivan County

Tioga County

Tompkins County

Ulster County

Warren County

Washington County

Wayne County

Westchester County

Wyoming County

Yates County