10 Best Places for a Bloody Mary in New York

Start with vodka, mix in some tomato juice, add a little Tabasco sauce, garnish it to your liking, and you've got yourself a Bloody Mary. Except it's not that simple. Bloody Marys are robust and dynamic cocktails. You can have them on a Sunday morning over brunch or a Friday night over dinner. You can add bacon to them or you can keep it simple with celery. For an amazing rendition on this classic cocktail, check out these 10 places in New York.   

The Colonial, Binghamton, NY

The Large & In Charge Bloody Marge is actually like eating an entire meal. It is served with mozzarella sticks, a slider, shrimp, wings, grilled cheese and veggies. Order this and you'll be stuffed! 

Buttermilk Channel, Brooklyn, NY

This is a southern-inspired restaurant located in the Carroll Gardens section of the borough. The owners provide three versions of a Bloody Mary along with the classic. The Star of the Sea cocktail comes with celery and peppercorn-infused vodka. It is served with an oyster. Another version is made with whiskey topped with stout. 

Trattoria Aroma, Buffalo, NY

A Bloody Mary menu is offered every Sunday. Options include the Aroma Mary, the Buffalo Bloody and the Hail Caesar. The Ragin’ Cajun blends clamato, fire roasted pepper and old bay seasoning topped with shrimp, olives, celery and lemon. A Slim Jim tops it off. 

Nick & Toni’s, East Hampton, NY

This restaurant’s Bloody Board is available on Sundays until Memorial Day, when brunch service is suspended for the summer season. Pick and choose to make a unique Bloody Mary. Choice of vodka, a carafe of mix and glasses filled with garnishes such as pickled fiddlehead ferns, and cherry bomb peppers.

Hammo’s Pub & Lodge, Hensonville, NY

This place is hidden in a small town near the Windham Mountain and Hunter Mountain ski areas. It offers an unbelievably delicious Bloody Mary with raw shrimp to top it off.

Cottage Café, Lake Placid, NY

On Mirror Lake, this is the place to build a unique and delicious Bloody Mary. Vodka options include things like Ketel One, Belvedere, Tito's, and Grey Goose. Then pick from a selection of garnishes such as traditional celery, pickle, Spanish olives, spicy olives, and spicy pickles. 

Nostalgia Ale House & Wine Bar, Malta, NY

The Sunday brunch menu includes a Bloody Mary Shrimp Cocktail. It is served with three shrimp soaking in the drink along with stuffed green olives.

Dirt Candy, New York, NY

The Bloody Carrie consists of grilled carrot juice, tomato, smoked habanero hot sauce, tequila and mezcal. It is served with a guajillo chili salt rim and pickles, carrots and tomatoes. The Jealous Mary is made with green tomato, kale juice, green Tabasco, vodka, and garnished with pickled green tomatoes. 

Phoenicia Diner, Phoenicia, NY

Phoenicia is a wonderful town in the Catskill Mountains. The diner is known for its breakfast dishes and the morning meal can be spiced up with its version of the Bloody Mary. Peace Vodka is distilled with pure Catskills mountain water, and that water is refreshing year-round.

Empire Brewing Company, Syracuse, NY

Grabbing a beer is the natural instinct at a brewery but consider this restaurant’s version of the Bloody Mary. The featured star on one of its cocktails is red snapper. 

Select a New York town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Find Bars Near You
Enter City / State or Zip code below
Select your town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you:

Albany County

Allegany County

Bronx County

Broome County

Cattaraugus County

Cayuga County

Chautauqua County

Chemung County

Chenango County

Clinton County

Columbia County

Cortland County

Delaware County

Dutchess County

Erie County

Essex County

Franklin County

Fulton County

Genesee County

Greene County

Hamilton County

Herkimer County

Jefferson County

Kings County

Lewis County

Livingston County

Madison County

Monroe County

Montgomery County

Nassau County

New York County

Niagara County

Oneida County

Onondaga County

Ontario County

Orange County

Orleans County

Oswego County

Otsego County

Putnam County

Queens County

Rensselaer County

Richmond County

Rockland County

Saint Lawrence County

Saratoga County

Schenectady County

Schoharie County

Schuyler County

Seneca County

Steuben County

Suffolk County

Sullivan County

Tioga County

Tompkins County

Ulster County

Warren County

Washington County

Wayne County

Westchester County

Wyoming County

Yates County