The 10 Best Bagel Shops in New York!

Soft and chewy on the inside and perfectly crispy on the outside, it’s safe to say the bagels in New York are unlike bagels made anywhere else. Whether it’s due to New York’s rich history of immigration or something in the water, the state is proud of its bagel heritage. These are 10 of the tastiest bagel shops in New York State.

1. Ess-A-Bagel, New York, NY

Known for its exceptionally large, fluffy bagels, Ess-A-Bagel has earned a loyal following and a reputation for making the best in the city. The shop often has a long line, but it’s worth the wait for the delicious bagel you’ll get at the end.

2. Hand Rolled Bagels, New Hyde Park, NY

This family-owned shop has earned a reputation for its exceptional-quality bagels made with New York City water. The staff hand-rolls the bagels every day and mixes the flavored cream cheese in-house. 

3. Russ & Daughters, New York, NY

This family-owned operation takes bagel-sandwich-making very seriously. They make their own lox with a salmon-slicer in house, and offer a huge selection of cream cheese and other toppings straight from Poland.

4. Tompkins Square Bagels, New York, NY

Hand-rolled every day, Tompkins Square Bagels crafts its bagels with care. The shop offers a variety of bagels and spreads and a breakfast/lunch menu that includes pancakes, eggs, and sandwiches.

5. Goldberg’s Famous Bagels, The Hamptons, NY

This East-End-of-Long-Island bagel chain has a large fan base of local and visiting bagel enthusiasts who eagerly queue up for its toasty bagels, flagels, and deli sandwiches.

6. Best Bagel & Coffee, New York, NY

With a name like “Best Bagel,” this place sets the bar high—and its big, fluffy bagels do not disappoint. The Penn Station-area bagel shop is a commuter hotspot with a perpetual-yet-fast-moving line that often stretches out the door.

7. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company, New York, NY

Churning out big, fluffy bagels efficiently and without fuss is what makes Brooklyn Bagel (which actually has no Brooklyn location) such a popular bagel spot. Critics say their perfectly soft, crispy bagels are among the best in the city.

8. Bagels on the Square, New York, NY

Bagels on the Square is a West Village staple, its friendly staff speedily doling out quality bagels to an endless line of hungry customers. The bagels are wonderful, the line moves fast, and you can head to the park across the street to people-watch afterward.

9. Bagel Boss, Hicksville, Long Island, NY

Regularly honored with the distinction of being the best bagel shop on Long Island, Bagel Boss makes an array of Kosher bagels and is open 24 hours a day. They also offer sandwiches, pastries, coffee, and catering.

10. Monticello Bagel Bakery, Monticello, NY

Located in New York’s official “Bagel Capital,” this historic bagel shop has been run by the Fleischman family since 1967. The bakery offers delicious bagels, catering services, and a drive-through window for those on-the-go cravings. 

Select a New York town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Find Bagel Shops Near You
Enter City / State or Zip code below
Select your town to find the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you:

Albany County

Allegany County

Bronx County

Broome County

Cattaraugus County

Cayuga County

Chautauqua County

Chemung County

Chenango County

Clinton County

Columbia County

Cortland County

Delaware County

Dutchess County

Erie County

Essex County

Franklin County

Fulton County

Genesee County

Greene County

Hamilton County

Herkimer County

Jefferson County

Kings County

Lewis County

Livingston County

Madison County

Monroe County

Montgomery County

Nassau County

New York County

Niagara County

Oneida County

Onondaga County

Ontario County

Orange County

Orleans County

Oswego County

Otsego County

Putnam County

Queens County

Rensselaer County

Richmond County

Rockland County

Saint Lawrence County

Saratoga County

Schenectady County

Schoharie County

Schuyler County

Seneca County

Steuben County

Suffolk County

Sullivan County

Tioga County

Tompkins County

Ulster County

Warren County

Washington County

Wayne County

Westchester County

Wyoming County

Yates County